Latest Automotive News

Subscribe in a reader

2008 Chevrolet Malibu Takes Top Spot in Mid-Size Sedan Comparison Test

Email   small font medium font large font

Web Editors Compare Six New Vehicles in Best-Selling Mid-Size Sedan Segment

The expert editors of Kelley Blue Book's recently conducted a highly comprehensive mid-size sedan value comparison test between six of the top new vehicles in the class and declared the 2008 Chevrolet Malibu winner. In an all-new video recently posted to the Latest News section of and, the editors round up the newest versions of the top-selling mid-size sedans -- Chevrolet Malibu, Honda Accord, Nissan Altima, Hyundai Sonata, Toyota Camry and Ford Fusion -- and detail their observations and opinions on each vehicle, ultimately declaring the Malibu the overall winner in the segment. In the spirit of the times, each of the vehicles tested in the 2008 mid-size sedan value comparison test were outfitted with standard four-cylinder engines and automatic transmissions (the way consumers purchase them most often), and five of the six models return highway fuel economy of at least 30 miles per gallon.

Every year since before the turn of the millennium, the mid-size sedan took top honors as the best-selling car in the country. The mid-size sedan's status as the definitive family car, however, has taken a hit due to the popularity of the SUV for many years. Now that gas prices and the economy have new-car buyers seeking better fuel economy and thinking small, the mid-size sedan is ready for a return to prominence. Combining varying levels of comfort, performance, value, amenities, roominess, safety and fuel economy, the mid-size sedan is just the answer many new-car buyers are looking for.

"The mid-size sedan segment is full of so many great options, and we set out to find the best of the best in overall value, and thus the best overall choice for consumers to consider, in this stellar group of popular cars," said Jack R. Nerad, executive editorial director and executive market analyst for Kelley Blue Book and "We were very impressed with all of the cars we tested, but our team found that the Chevy Malibu simply was the best all-around in its class. The others just don't quite measure up to all the Malibu has to offer in terms of interior and exterior styling, performance, safety and overall value."

The comprehensive value comparison tests conducted by the entire editorial staff included scoring multiple points of consideration for each vehicle in each of the following categories: exterior, interior, driving dynamics, safety (both active and passive safety), crash ratings, and value (examining both New Car Blue Book® Values, which are the actual transaction values of what each vehicle is currently selling for, as well as projected future resale values). 2008 Mid-Size Sedan Comparison Test Rankings & Editorial Comments

1. 2008 Chevrolet Malibu

The newest Chevy Malibu just seems to do everything well. Not only does it look great inside and out, it's also smooth on the highway, remarkably quiet and still eager around town and in the hills. From its artistically sculpted exterior design to its lush, upscale interior, this is a car that recalls the days when General Motors set the style leadership for the world. Our testers were impressed with what we regarded as its uncanny balance of ride and handling, and the Malibu also delivers best-in-class fuel economy. The Malibu simply is the closest thing there is to a one-size-fits-all mid-size family sedan.

2. 2008 Honda Accord

The Honda Accord brings world-class refinement to the mainstream. Save for a few polarizing elements such as the design and layout of the audio and climate controls, the Honda could easily have taken home the trophy. Several praised its sporty handling, but a few of us felt the Accord offered a ride that was a little too stiff for the family sedan class. On the safety front, Accord offers a remarkable level of active and passive safety equipment. In the ownership-cost area, its high resale value was accompanied by a high initial price, and its projected fuel costs were higher than most competitors. By a very close margin, our testers deemed its exterior design and execution, as well as its driving dynamics, number one in the class, besting even the Malibu.

3. 2008 Nissan Altima

Though the Nissan Altima's exterior styling seems a little long in the tooth to some, its sporty handling and smooth continuously variable automatic transmission impressed our editors. Testers liked the excellent rear-seat access, strong technology package offerings and the very visible, intuitive instrument panel. In safety, the Altima fell short of its competitors because important active safety items like traction control and stability control are optional rather than standard, but its high relative resale value and low fuel costs helped the Altima to gain high marks on the price-value comparison.

4. 2009 Hyundai Sonata

The refreshed-for-2009 Hyundai Sonata features, by most accounts, a markedly improved interior with seemingly high-quality materials and a simple dash with high-mounted audio controls that garnered praise from our testers. It doesn't have the same level of to-the-bone refinement as the others, but by some measurements it's indeed the best bang for the buck. Strong safety performance and positive overall value helped move Sonata into an impressive fourth-place finish.

5. 2008 Toyota Camry

For some buyers, the sales-leading, smooth-riding, straightforward, reputable Toyota Camry is the best mid-size sedan on the market. Others might want something less ho-hum. In this comparison, its run-of-the-mill exterior and interior styling and execution plus uninspiring driving dynamics pushed it lower on the list than many would have predicted. However, Camry scored quite well on the safety front, and its high resale value and straightforward dash won praise from the editors.

6. 2008 Ford Fusion

In this field of strong contenders, all it took for the Ford Fusion to wind up in last place was to lose a point here and a point there, particularly with its four-star crash ratings in several areas compared to the five-star ratings of its competitors. However, we particularly liked its upscale interior and logical, easy to understand controls. Some felt the Fusion's ride and handling balance was the best of the bunch and ideal for the category, but we were disappointed that it lacked a shift-it-yourself feature on the automatic transmission, and we also were distressed by the lack of electronic stability control even as an option.

Receive the latest automotive news by email!

Enter your email address:

Related news
KelleyBlueBook, the leading provider of new and used vehicle information, announces the Chevrolet Malibu as the winner of the “2008 Best Redesigned Vehicle” award. According to the editorial team, the newly redesigned 2008 ...
It’s been approximately six months since Chevrolet’s redesigned Malibu was launched. In that time, it has received critical acclaim – including being named 2008 North American Car of the Year – and numerous ...
Chevrolet’s popular, award-winning 2008 Malibu offers an expanded range of customer choices this spring, with an efficient four-cylinder/six-speed automatic combination offered on LTZ models. A 2.4L Ecotec engine is partnered with a ...
The expert editors at Kelley Blue Book’s, the leading provider of new- and used-vehicle information, today announce their picks for the Top 10 Coolest New Cars Under $18,000. The vehicles that made Kelley ...
The expert editors of Kelley Blue Book’s, the leading provider of new- and used-vehicle information, today announce their picks for Kelley Blue Book’s 2008 Top 10 Best New Road Trip Vehicles. Memorial Day ...
All-New 2008 Chevrolet Malibu Delivers A Lot Of Value Starting At $19,995 ...
Chevrolet Showcases the all new 2008 Malibu at the 20th Anniversary Celebration of Univision's Premio Lo Nuestro Chevrolet's first year as Exclusive Automotive Sponsor ...
For the second consecutive year, a car from General Motors Corporation has taken top honors in the North American Car and Truck of the Year (NACTOY) awards, as announced today at the ...
Malibu Hybrid production begins in October, available at dealerships soon after ...

Best Investment Newsletter

- 46% in 2008

- invest in the best performing US stocks only and sell them when the uptrend is over

- very easy to follow, simple buy/sell signals

- no need to have investing or trading experience

Find More Now!

2008 Chevrolet Malibu Takes Top Spot in Mid-Size Sedan Comparison Test
> © 2006-2017 except where otherwise noted