There is glitz, gleam and endless oohs and ahhs
expected from the kilometres of metal on display at the North
American International Auto Show.
Yet it comes to a state whose economy has been generating more
groans than glee, with the highest unemployment rate in the United
States and among the highest rates of home foreclosures _ largely
due to its dependence on a domestic auto industry that's been
cutting jobs and closing plants.
The national economic picture also is showing signs of stalling.
The government reported last week that the unemployment rate surged
to five per cent in December _ the biggest one-month gain since
October 2001. And many of the big chain retail stores reported
Thursday that the holiday shopping season turned out to be even
weaker than expected, raising more worries about consumer spending
in the months ahead.
The disconnect isn't lost on business and economic leaders and
experts. But they say the auto show, which opens to the media Sunday
and then to the public Jan. 19, affords a chance to celebrate
without cheer-leading and offers examples of innovation on a global
scale in a time Michigan and perhaps the country could use more of
it.
``The choice is not to hide, take a bunker mentality,'' said
David Sowerby, portfolio manager and chief market analyst for Loomis
Sayles & Co. ``Recognize that industry needs to get better ...
(while) celebrating what's good in the industry.''
Sowerby was hired by the Detroit Area Dealers' Association, the
auto show's organizer, to conduct an economic impact study. He found
that it could generate up to US$500 million in the local economy,
including money made by local restaurants, hotels and workers.
More than 1,000 workers have been at downtown Detroit's Cobo
Center since October, transforming the convention space into a
buzzing business district _ if that district consisted solely of
shiny, sleek car dealer showrooms with dazzling interactive displays
and even a two-story waterfall. Organizers declined to say how much
the exhibits cost, but it appears to be at least on par with the
reported $200 million spent last year.
Sowerby said the show also delivers substance by unveiling more
than 50 new models among the roughly 700 vehicles on display. ``To
me, it doesn't make the show 'too much sizzle.'''
Still, the economic boost comes amid an overall sag. Michigan's
unemployment rate was 7.4 per cent in November, the latest month for
which state figures are available. Michigan was also the top state
for home foreclosure starts in the third quarter of 2007, according
to the Mortgage Bankers Association.
And unlike other parts of the country, the state's losses come as
a result of its declining manufacturing base, stagnant population
growth and low demand for housing.
According to the U.S. Commerce Department, motor vehicles were 25
per cent of Michigan's gross domestic product in 1965. Forty years
later, it's just under seven per cent. By contrast, autos were 2.5
per cent of the national GDP in 1965 and below one per cent in 2005.
``We have diversified our economy, but more by subtraction than
by addition,'' said Charles Ballard, an economics professor at
Michigan State University. ``We're much less diversified than many
other states.''
Detroit automaker General Motors Corp. (NYSE:GM), Ford Motor Co.
(NYSE:F) have spent the last two years shedding tens of thousands of
jobs and restructuring. Chrysler LLC _ which Daimler AG sold last
year to the private equity firm Cerberus Capital Management LP _
announced up to 25,000 layoffs last year alone.
Now automakers are concerned about the slowing U.S. market just
as they are about to reap savings from those job cuts, globalization
and a new cost-saving labour contract.
Already GM, Ford and Chrysler have announced production cuts in
the first quarter in anticipation of slowing demand.
Ballard said it's difficult for politicians and residents to
comprehend the economic transformation that's taken place,
particularly when heavy manufacturing in the 1950s and '60s powered
Michigan's economy to phenomenal success. Those attitudes linger, he
said.
``It helped to create a set of attitudes that were, if not
exactly hostile to innovation and entrepreneurship, it didn't foster
(them), said Ballard. ``I think we're racing to catch up with the
rest of the country.''
He said the auto show can be a motivating force if advanced
technology, such as the plug-in hybrids and electronic concept
vehicles _ including three being unveiled this year by Chrysler _
could galvanize the industry. That could be a boon for the state, he
said.
Carl Galeana, the auto show's senior co-chairman and longtime
local auto dealer, said the show has changed and grown with the
times. It started in 1907 as a local show that cost 50 cents to
attend and this year is marking its 20th year as an international
event that draws more than 6,700 journalists from 42 countries.